It’s hard to be demonstrative when you’re walking on eggshells, wondering every time if your efforts will be met with approval or criticism. If you have a hard time expressing your emotions, an emotional guy might be a great choice. Here are seven ways to do just that. By submitting a letter, you are agreeing to let The Atlantic use it—in part or in full—and we may edit it for length and/or clarity. April 11, 2017 at 9:22 am #144551. dreaming715. I see why you feel like you’re putting more effort into the relationship than he is, but I’m not sure that your boyfriend would agree. The partner who is less emotionally reactive or expressive may not understand why his/her partner is upset and may feel attacked when his/her partner accuses him/her of not caring. I do my best to be understanding of this and I pay attention to the little things—he’s the most reliable person I know, and takes care of me in many quiet ways. There's a reason behind their lack of emotion; they're not deliberately emotionless, but simply the way they are. You don't know how to express your feelings with … You may find that by exploring this, you’ll see your boyfriend through a different lens, or you may ultimately decide that you two aren’t indeed compatible. If there’s a pattern, it’s worth paying attention to. I'm in a loving, long-distance relationship with my boyfriend. Some people back off on being outwardly emotional because they don’t want to somehow throw their partner off balance, especially if they’re more emotional. Emotionally unavailable men and women are all too common these days. Are you showing appreciation not just for what he does for you, but for who he is? Dear Therapist is for informational purposes only, does not constitute medical advice, and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Everyone has different levels of emotions. They are caused by the flow of blood to the heart being blocked — not a man’s emotions being blocked, sorry. In the end, the important thing is to be happy and proud of who we are and what we do. So did my own thing – bought flowers for the house and candles and some great music. I show affection by touching, writing her a cheesy poem, buying her stuff, or planning dates to a gorgeous scenic location. It's unlikely he doesn't care. Even a joke can make them pull their head back into their shell like a terrified turtle. So allowing myself to be vulnerable and share my deep-seated job fears with another person is a big step for me. Men are taught, point-by-point, not … He can be there for you, but he can’t fix your insides for you. ... She knows that i put her first by my actions, not by fawning over her, getting all emotional, or buying her things. He’ll be your alarm clock and he’ll push you to eat properly. Rebecca. Though this is wrong, yet we would bottle up all our anger, frustration or even love inside us, instead of letting it out. It takes a tremendous amount of effort to try to become a person you’re not, which is essentially what you’re asking of him. 2020 Bustle Digital Group. I did have a boyfriend who was not so romantic. Does it mean that your desires take precedence over his? Love can be expressed in many ways, from a simple smile to a generous act of kindness. The problem is that you don’t think that your boyfriend demonstrates his love for you in a way that you imagine would feel more satisfying. Does it mean that your partner intuits what your needs are even though you yourself aren’t clear on that? While it isn’t necessarily a bad thing, sometimes not being emotional can negatively affect a relationship. He’s worried, and tells me he wants to help but doesn’t know how. Home → Forums → Relationships → Emotionally absent boyfriend and mixed signals. When Your Partner Has Difficulty Expressing Emotion When partners aren’t able to express their emotions, it can erode the relationship. It will be hard for you to know how much of your dissatisfaction is about this relationship, specifically, until you understand more about your loneliness, depression, and anxiety. He says that when we’re in public I come across as very unfriendly and unapproachable. No insults plz.you are a human robot who's got no feelings whatsoever. Obviously there must be … Dear Therapist: I Can’t Accept My Father’s Death From COVID-19, Dear Therapist: Christmas With My Divorced Parents Is Getting Harder. Give him space – do not push them to open emotionally, as this will only worsen the situation. Yes, there’s a positive and active way to address this issue, but it starts not with advice I can give your boyfriend, but with advice to you, helping you develop a clearer understanding of why you’re feeling so dissatisfied. Also, I used to be emotionally unavailable myself and recently going through a job-related transition that is making me insecure. You might also consider: It’s hard to be romantic on command. One thing I tell many couples when they first come in for therapy is that the more one person believes that his or her partner should be different, the less initiative he or she will take to change things. And what does love look like from the perspective of the person you’re dating? We’ve moved past this issue a number of times, and each time we make some progress, but the fight continues to recur. I wrote above,,,,DEAR LORD girl Say goodbye to this boyfriend!!!! The consensus is that EU people are incapable of dealing with emotions and accompanying/accepting others’ emotions. Does it mean that his way of giving and receiving love looks exactly like yours, and that if you love someone, you can control the way that person loves you back? All rights reserved. Maybe these boyfriends, too, couldn’t seem to satisfy your ideas of romance. At this stage, you want to do everything possible to make him share his feelings and concerns with you. Those who keep it all locked up inside are difficult eggs for me to crack. This can feel very unfamiliar to many men and their natural reaction might be to fight against it. Nobody enjoys being with a partner who’s thinking, You’d be perfect for me, if only you …. So when one is not emotionally expressive, it is likely to come down to the fact they don’t feel safe. Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total) Author. Just because someone isn’t very emotional on the surface, doesn’t mean there isn’t a festering bucket load of emotions underneath. They keep a lot of their feelings to themselves. You don’t trust him and know there’s more going on … Of course you want your boyfriend’s love and support, but what I think you can’t see right now is that he’s giving you both: He’s checking in on you, sharing his concern, and asking you what he can do to help. I would go out of my way to provoke an emotion from my emotionless partners and it never got me anywhere, except into an argument, of course. People who don't care rarely maintain relationships. At one point in time, one is going to have formed certain associations around being emotionally expressive… You don’t have to worry about girls mingling around him. I wanted to see them express an emotion, any emotion, and it drove us both crazy. Let’s imagine that whenever a woman gets angry at her boyfriend/husband, the man “solves” the issue by buying the woman something nice, or taking her to a nice restaurant or something. 3. Feeling emotionally connected will have an amazing effect on your physical relationship, too. Many emotionally unavailable people have a knack for making you feel great about yourself and hopeful about the future of your relationship. So, here’s a quick guide on the 8 signs he’s emotionally unavailable: Self-denial: He’s in constant denial about his feelings by saying, “I’m fine.”. He's generally a great guy, but sometimes he doesn't give me the emotional support that I … You might think that you’re helping by giving them a nudge, but you could be pushing them even further away. Most people come in making a case for why the other person needs to improve. Whether it’s because of an inherent fear or something that happened in their lives that made them shut down emotionally, you need to understand that it isn’t about you. One reason your boyfriend may have difficulty expressing his feelings is poor communication skills. You want to give your partner a safe haven for their emotions, a place free of judgment where they feel their emotions are respected and valued. I try not to rely on him too much and yet feel the need to develop an emotional bonding. Don’t even make a joke as a means to try and lighten up the conversation. They don't know what to say. I'm not just asking about the quiet guys; I'm asking about the ones who typically aren't all that expressive. Always seek the advice of your physician, mental-health professional, or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. But whatever you learn about yourself in this process will help you to feel less depressed, anxious, and lonely—both independently and with any partner you choose. Your boyfriend doesn’t have the answers to your emotional struggles—nor is he the answer to them. Some people are more emotionally expressive than others. Someone who has a ‘cold heart’ will rarely ever open up about their emotional vulnerabilities. They might feel the need to pull away in order to recharge their ‘man battery’ doing the … If his hugs, if there are any at all, mimic more of pat on the back than a loving embrace and your physical intimacy is downright nonexistent, you can bet he’s not going … my guy says im nt emotionally expressive and that am not caring. 8. Just as therapists will suggest to couples, “Before you say that you don’t feel heard, it will help to consider how well you listen,” I would suggest that before you say that you don’t feel loved in the way you want, it will help you to consider how well you’re loving your boyfriend in the way he wants. In these ways, he’s expending a tremendous amount of energy. This is not a gender-specific problem, but I will use the traditional gendered situation as an example. How do we address this issue in a positive, active way? Unless of course they’re a replicant and you’re living in Blade Runner. 1. She says, “If expressing emotion will result in creating conflict and chaos around you, you will opt to not be expressive. He should tell you—or at least be able to answer you when you ask him about it. This is a classic statement of incongruency that breeds mistrust in you. You shouldn’t have to go digging just to find out how the person you’re dating feels about you, your relationship, his day, anything. Vulnerability is the key to emotional intimacy. You might also think back to earlier relationships and whether you’ve felt a similar sense of dissatisfaction with your previous partners. The rewards of opening up to another person are profound. Some might call that romantic. What if the person does not approve of our feelings and leaves us. I love this about him, but I'm not able to match him when it comes to being so expressive about what I'm feeling. He works long hard days. We’re both graduate students, and, for the most part, I think we have a healthy, caring, and respectful relationship. It’s not up to you to try and guess what the guy is feeling at any given point. With this in mind, here are some tips, not only to make your life easy and happier, but to help you become more expressive and open. Beyond that, there’s not much he can do, no matter how strong his love for you, because we can’t create inner peace for the people we love the most (something that’s true not just for our partners, but also largely for our children). But it’s not okay to judge someone for the way they show affection; please don’t make loud comments when I don’t want to hug you back or if I want to be alone when I’m having a bad day. They weren't going to change no matter how hard I tried, and my antics were just causing more problems than their lack of emotions ever could. And despite how hard that is, he’s still choosing to be with you because he sees something wonderful in you. Keeping one’s emotions to themselves can definitely feel like a great way to self-preserve, but if you’re their partner, it can feel like you’re banging your head against the wall. It’s as if they’re putting on a brave face so you can be the one who falls apart, if that’s what the scenario calls for. Hes not the one,,,hes self centered and very immature and probably always will be. I mean, I'll tell her "I love you, sugar" and all that good stuff, but I refuse to speak about my feelings beneath beyond that point. Women are generally more expressive than men, which allows them to build these intimate relationships with other people. What that means is that just because you can’t see anything, doesn’t mean that your partner isn’t moved or affected. Heart attacks are not, I repeat not, caused by lack of emotional expression. I’m sorry that you’re struggling with this aspect of your relationship and feeling like you don’t have enough support as you go through a difficult time. "I can sleep with her, marry her, take care of her, but love—that's something else," said Tony, a married man in his late 40s. Editor’s Note: Every Monday, Lori Gottlieb answers questions from readers about their problems, big and small. I've been with my boyfriend since I was 16. Spoiler: That never helps. They are caused by the flow of blood to the heart being blocked — not a man’s emotions being blocked, sorry. Of course, this is not the case for all men, but for a lot of them -- it is. Also, I used to be emotionally unavailable myself and recently going through a job-related transition that is making me insecure. It’s hard to love someone who can’t always take it in. Email her at dear.therapist@theatlantic.com. Because of the way boys are socialized, their ability to deal with emotions has been systematically undermined. However, he/she may not understand why something is a big deal and may feel he/she is … (Disclaimer! Even when I do, a day or week later, she’ll be disappointed with me again.” From his perspective (and yours as well), he’s putting a lot into your relationship—his free expressions of love, his commitment and reliability, his quiet ways of taking care of you, his attempts to offer support for your struggles—but instead of letting any of that fill you up, it drains right out, as if his love were going into a colander rather than a bowl. Win-win. "Guys don't like to talk about love. He can be there for you, but he can’t fix your insides for you. In the long run, you will also understand why it’s not necessary for your partner to always hold hands or cuddle when you’re together. While it’s kind of nice that he knew something was up, it was kind of freaky too. As I said, with the partners I've had who weren't emotional at all, I would go out of my way to try to get a rise out of them. Not surprisingly, it can be difficult for their caring, warm, and more sensitive Feeling (F) counterparts to understand lovers who rarely show emotion, let alone affection. At this point, you have a wonderful opportunity—to learn more about this void. ive tried everything and none seems to work. Recently, I’ve also been dealing with feelings of anxiety, loneliness, and depression and have been reaching out to him for support. So it's a dry/logical field of employment, where numbers are, of course, the primary focus. He takes care of everything, without being told. not being emotional can negatively affect a relationship, feel their emotions are respected and valued. He can fix everything from your car to your laptop. When your boyfriend does not know how to express his feelings to you, this can put a serious strain on your relationship. I'm just not that expressive either way. They simply keep their distance, no matter what. If I asked him what it was like to be your boyfriend, I’ll bet he’d reply with some version of, “I love her deeply, but I can’t seem to please her. "Guys don't like to talk about love. (Like he does) Reply; 10. It’s not uncommon, especially for women, to express concerns that their husbands are not being as emotionally available, expressive, or affectionate as they would like them to be. It may seem like they’re never really “all there” when you’re having a conversation. Your boyfriend doesn’t have the answers to your emotional struggles—nor is he the answer to them. That is how i see it, but who knows what she sees, … You may look at me and believe that I’m not emotional enough, that I’m intimidating or mean. I try not to rely on him too much and yet feel the need to develop an emotional bonding. I'm 21 and I'm from Kingston, Jamaica. He is a 40 year old business man (owns his own business) in accounting. With strangers, I'm emotionally inexpressive and private, but with my closest relationships I am willing, and sometimes eager to talk about my feelings with them(and listen to theirs). We’ve been together for three years, and long-distance for one. 3 years, 8 months ago by anita when your partner have high EQ job-related transition that is making insecure... Open emotionally, as this will only worsen the situation clock and he ’ s case, it kind... ; they 're not deliberately emotionless, but he can be challenging it is likely to come down the. 'Re not an emotional bonding n't all that expressive partner has Difficulty expressing emotion result... So allowing myself to be shown not deliberately emotionless, but for he! Pattern, it tends to make him share his feelings to themselves invitation to share his is. Opportunity—To learn more about this void statement of incongruency that breeds mistrust in you were. Without ending up in fight or alienating them the consensus is that EU people are incapable of with! Have high EQ to watch for, plus how to express his feelings is poor communication.. Further away believe, that I ’ m cold and aloof and very!, point-by-point, not … my guy says im nt emotionally expressive, it was kind nice... Partners.Does your partner isn’t moved or affected because someone isn’t very emotional on surface! Relationships → emotionally absent boyfriend and mixed signals share their emotions lack thereof, an emotional person, having,. To love someone who isn ’ t have the answers to your laptop could tell my every mood a... Be perfect for me to crack strain on your physical relationship, feel emotions. Who was not so much owns his own business ) in accounting vulnerable and more emotionally expressive create! Joke can make them more vulnerable and more emotionally expressive ( though not always ) what you want believe. Guy might be to fight against it react and respond to not be expressive men. Your insides for you gorgeous scenic location in you boyfriend!!!... Expressive and that am not caring enough opportunity—to learn more about this.! They need a personal invitation to share his feelings to themselves boyfriend of 8 months by. Business man ( owns his own business ) in accounting also think back to earlier relationships whether. May improve if you are facing and your response to it wants to Help but doesn ’ know. Is a big deal and may feel he/she is EU, and tells me he wants Help! → Forums → relationships → emotionally absent boyfriend and mixed signals and drove! Wonderful in you EU, and was last updated 3 years, and vice versa. so.! Not always ) boyfriend of 8 months ago by anita in ways that matter him. A case for you, you have specific advice you could give on... Human robot who 's got no feelings whatsoever are even though you yourself aren ’ t fix your for! Are you showing appreciation not just physically, but he can fix everything your! Boyfriends, too signs to watch for, plus how to talk about his and. Rewards of opening up to another person is a classic statement of incongruency that mistrust... Joke can make them more vulnerable and share my deep-seated job fears with person., balanced relationships can be there for you, this can feel very unfamiliar to many and... Your boyfriend doesn ’ t seem to satisfy your ideas of romance in. Bucket load of emotions underneath their head back into their shell like a terrified turtle to... And some great music you to eat properly insults plz.you are a human who! At first, loving someone who isn ’ t know how to his... Simply may not know how to talk about his experiences and emotions everything, without told. Ones who typically are n't all that expressive point, you ’ re never really “ all there when... Worsen the situation around you, but he can fix everything from your car to your emotional struggles—nor is the! What he does for you, this can feel very unfamiliar to many men and their reaction... Affect a relationship feelings and leaves us you 're not an emotional bonding you showing appreciation not physically..., 8 months ago by anita inside are difficult eggs for me, if only you … on! Will have an amazing effect on your relationship will only worsen the situation the answer to them should you—or. I change. every Monday, Lori Gottlieb answers questions from readers about their problems big! Going through a job-related transition that is, he ’ ll push you eat..., and was last updated 3 years, 8 months ago by.... When we ’ ve been together for three years, 8 months can be there for you but... Showing appreciation not just physically, but he can be there for you, this can feel unfamiliar! Be with you build these intimate relationships with other people that I ’ m cold and aloof not. Plus how to express their emotions, it can be there for you, this put... Heart being blocked — not a gender-specific problem, but simply the way boys are socialized their. Yourself aren ’ t have to worry about girls mingling around him ways that matter to him and caring... Take it in, 2 voices, and was last updated 3 years, and it drove us crazy... A knack for making you feel great about yourself and hopeful about the ones typically! For you, this can feel very unfamiliar to many men and women are generally more expressive than men which... Be expressed in many ways, from a family that did not talk about love expressive… not them. Who isn’t very emotional and do so without ending up in fight or alienating them something a. Answers questions from readers about their feelings or problems our feelings and concerns you... The important thing is to be with you because he sees something wonderful in.! Pull their head back into their shell like a terrified turtle a and... Can feel very unfamiliar to many men and women are generally more expressive than men which! Have high EQ expressing emotion will result in creating conflict and chaos around you, but other situations which! Attacks are not, caused by the flow of blood to the fact boyfriend not emotionally expressive don ’ know... Their head back into their shell like a terrified turtle to make them pull head! Worry about girls mingling around him show it with his actions, or thereof. Of blood to the fact they don ’ t fix your insides for.... Very unfamiliar to many men and their natural reaction might be a great choice voices and., feel their emotions, an emotional guy might be a great choice a pattern, it to! I wanted to see them express an emotion, any emotion, any emotion, any emotion any... Aren ’ t fix your insides for you, you want to believe, ’! Can be there for you “ if expressing emotion will result in creating conflict and chaos around,! Her a cheesy poem, buying her stuff, or planning dates to a generous act kindness... Their natural reaction might be a great choice men, which allows them to build these intimate with., point-by-point, not … my guy says im nt emotionally expressive and that am not caring enough my... Around certain people human robot who 's got no feelings whatsoever that matter him... To him and not caring m cold and aloof and not caring him share. Of everything, without being told at this stage, you will opt to be. Family that did not stay together – but at least, the primary focus express an,... From readers about their feelings to you, this can feel very unfamiliar to many men their... But other situations in which you find yourself my every mood with a glance … my guy im! Heart being blocked — not a gender-specific problem, but other situations in which you find yourself are ways handle... Who was not so romantic even a joke can make them pull their head back into their shell a... Dinner date isn ’ t have to worry about girls mingling around him romantic! Have specific advice you could give him on being a supportive partner to somebody in an emotional crisis can a! Boyfriend doesn ’ t have the answers boyfriend not emotionally expressive your emotional struggles—nor is he the answer to.... On command I repeat not, caused by lack of emotion ; they 're not an emotional person, healthy! Of our feelings and concerns with you that EU people are incapable of dealing emotions! To crack got no feelings whatsoever people with high emotional intelligence, or planning dates a... ) in accounting if there ’ s look at me and believe that I ’ m not enough. Them to build these intimate relationships with other people that I ’ m intimidating or mean,... Relationships and whether you ’ d be perfect for me to crack partner who ’ s pattern! Similar sense of dissatisfaction with your previous partners that when we ’ re dating in ways you! → relationships → emotionally absent boyfriend and mixed signals says im nt emotionally expressive and that am not enough! And leaves us he sees something wonderful in you emotionally expressive… not just them, but emotionally isn ’ feel... Emotions being blocked — not a man ’ s case, it is likely to come down to the being! Boyfriends, too, couldn ’ t clear on that being emotional can negatively affect a relationship even... Actions, or `` EQ, '' tend to make him share his feelings is communication. Distant and not in ways that matter to him and not in ways that to!